When Healthy Habits Become an Obsession

Learning to find balance, one cup of coffee at a time.

I have a confession to make.

My morning coffee has been hiding a little secret from me. ☕️😂

Well, technically, the coffee wasn’t hiding anything. I just wasn’t measuring what I was putting in it.

For months, I’ve been logging my morning coffee at 246 calories. I thought I had a pretty good handle on what was going into that big 20-ounce Yeti.

Then I decided to actually measure my half-and-half and sweet cream creamer.

425 CALORIES!

Y’all, I about fell out of my chair! 🤦🏻‍♀️

I thought surely I’d done something wrong. Maybe I hadn’t zeroed out the scale correctly. So I measured everything again the next morning.

Nope. Those numbers were right.

Almost 180 extra calories every single morning that I wasn’t accounting for.

And that wasn’t the only surprise my coffee had waiting for me.

The Blood Sugar Surprise

Since stopping Mounjaro, I’ve been keeping a closer eye on my blood sugar. My doctor and I agreed to monitor how things go, and I want to do everything I reasonably can to keep my numbers in a healthy range.

That’s where my Dexcom comes in.

Yesterday morning, I had my usual coffee, and my blood sugar rose to approximately 145–150 mg/dL before coming back down to 95 two hours after I started drinking it.

This morning, I had the same coffee, with the same measured ingredients.

My blood sugar climbed to 170 mg/dL.

Now, it did come back down to around 100, which was encouraging.

But here’s what caught my attention.

I hadn’t eaten anything else.

Just my morning coffee.

Now, I’m not saying the sweet cream creamer is definitely responsible. Caffeine, sleep, stress, and other factors can influence blood sugar, too.

But considering the amount of sweetened creamer I’ve been using, it’s certainly worth investigating.

And suddenly, that innocent-looking bottle in my refrigerator isn’t looking quite so innocent anymore! 😂

Sometimes the Little Things Add Up

I love my morning coffee.

It’s part of my routine. I look forward to it, and I’m not interested in giving it up.

But I am interested in making it work better for me.

So I’ve ordered a smaller, 14-ounce Yeti to replace my 20-ounce cup.

And once my current creamer is gone, I’m planning to try something different, preferably with less added sugar.

In the meantime, I can start reducing how much I use and watch what happens to my blood sugar.

Because here’s something I’m learning:

Just because we’ve always done something a certain way doesn’t mean we can’t make it better.

Sometimes a small adjustment can make a meaningful difference.

And sometimes we need to question the habits we’ve gotten so comfortable with that we don’t even think about them anymore.

When Tracking Takes Over

All this coffee business got me thinking about something bigger.

I’ve lost over 100 pounds. And along the way, I’ve learned a lot about nutrition, portion sizes, protein, fiber, and how different foods affect my body.

Tracking my food has been an important part of that journey.

But somewhere along the way, I started paying so much attention to the numbers that I sometimes forgot to pay attention to myself.

I’d look at my food tracker and see that I hadn’t reached my protein goal. Or my fiber goal. Or whatever number I was trying to hit that day.

And what would I do?

I’d start looking for something else to eat.

Even when I wasn’t hungry.

Think about that for a minute.

Here I am, trying to build a healthier relationship with food, and I’m occasionally forcing myself to eat just to make a number on an app look better.

Something about that doesn’t sit right with me anymore.

The Numbers Are Tools, Not Rules

Don’t get me wrong. I’m not throwing away my food tracker.

And I’m certainly not ignoring my blood sugar.

Those numbers provide valuable information, especially as I navigate life without Mounjaro and continue working toward my weight-loss goals.

But there’s a difference between using information to make decisions and allowing that information to control every decision.

I don’t want every meal to feel like a math problem.

I don’t want to spend my evenings wondering how I’m going to squeeze in another 20 grams of protein when I’m already satisfied.

And I don’t want to feel like I’ve failed because I didn’t hit every single target.

Tracking should help me understand my habits, not make me afraid to live my life.

My coffee is actually a perfect example.

Without tracking, I might never have realized how many calories I was drinking.

Without my Dexcom, I might not have noticed the glucose rise after my morning coffee.

But those discoveries don’t mean I need to panic or give up something I enjoy.

They mean I have information I can use to make a better choice.

That’s what tracking is supposed to do.

Learning to Trust Myself Again

This next chapter of my health journey is going to look a little different.

I’m no longer taking Mounjaro, and naturally, there’s a little nervousness that comes with that.

I’ve worked hard to lose over 100 pounds, and I want to keep moving forward.

I also want to keep my blood sugar where it needs to be.

But I want to enjoy my life along the way.

I want to eat when I’m hungry, stop when I’m comfortably satisfied, and make nutritious choices without feeling like every bite has to satisfy a spreadsheet.

That doesn’t mean ignoring nutrition or pretending calories don’t matter.

It means finding a middle ground between being informed and being consumed by the information.

I’m still learning where that middle ground is.

And after losing more than 100 pounds, you’d think I’d have it all figured out by now.

Spoiler alert: I don’t! 😂

Progress Doesn’t Require Perfection

I think sometimes we get so caught up in doing everything right that we forget why we started in the first place.

We wanted to feel better. Be healthier. Have more energy. Enjoy our lives.

We didn’t start this journey so we could spend the rest of our lives worrying about whether we ate exactly 112 grams of protein on a Tuesday.

At least, I didn’t.

So I’m giving myself permission to make adjustments.

To learn.

To enjoy my coffee.

To celebrate my birthday without guilt.

To pay attention to what my body is telling me.

And to remember that one imperfect day doesn’t erase years of hard work.

I’ll still track my food. I’ll still monitor my blood sugar. I’ll still work toward my goals.

But I’m going to try a little harder to listen to my body along the way.

Because healthy living shouldn’t feel like a punishment.

And if finding that balance starts with trading my 20-ounce Yeti for a 14-ounce one and giving my sweet cream creamer a little side-eye?

Well, that’s a pretty good place to begin. ☕️😂

Sometimes the biggest lessons come from the smallest habits.

Small steps. Real support. Healthier together.

— Rese

Unknown's avatar

Author: Rese

Hi, I'm Rese! ❤️ I'm a wellness enthusiast, a book lover, and a firm believer that getting healthy is about so much more than losing weight. My journey has been anything but ordinary. From navigating life-changing health challenges to losing over 100 pounds, I've learned that progress isn't always measured by a number on the scale. And while I still have more weight I'd like to lose, I'm learning to appreciate how far I've come instead of focusing only on how far I have left to go. Through Get Healthy with Us, I hope to encourage others to build healthier habits, celebrate small victories, and give themselves a little grace along the way. I also love sharing pieces of everyday life, the lessons I'm learning, and a little laughter when things don't go quite as planned. I'm still learning, still growing, and still figuring things out—one day, one healthy habit, and one cup of coffee at a time. ☕❤️

Leave a Reply